PPF vs FD vs NPS: A Simple Comparison
What each of these three popular options is good for, and how to test the numbers yourself.
These three get compared constantly, but they do different jobs. Treating them as rivals leads to confusion. Treat them as tools.
PPF: safe and long
The Public Provident Fund has a 15-year lock-in, a government-set rate that changes every quarter, and tax-free interest. It suits people who want guaranteed, tax-efficient savings for a long goal. The PPF calculator shows the maturity value for any yearly deposit.
FD: flexible and predictable
A fixed deposit lets you choose the term, from a few months to a few years. The rate is fixed at booking, but the interest is taxed as income. It works well for short goals and for parking an emergency fund. Try the FD calculator for different tenures and compounding.
NPS: retirement only
The National Pension System invests in a mix of equity and debt, and you cannot freely withdraw before retirement. A large part has to be used to buy an annuity. It rewards people who will not touch the money. The NPS calculator estimates the corpus and the pension.
How to choose
Ask what the money is for and when you need it. Under five years: FD. Fifteen years and a wish for safe, tax-free growth: PPF. Retirement with some tolerance for market ups and downs: NPS. Many people use all three for different goals.
Tax rules and rates change, so check the current rules before you invest.